There’s one thing that’s true about us goldfish folks:
We love ourselves some FISH!
It may be because we might have a suspicion that our goldfish is lonely and wants a friend, or simply because we want to add some interest to our goldfish tank by adding another species into the mix.
So I can’t count how many times I’ve heard:
“What fish can live with goldfish?”
Good question.
To answer it, we’ve put together a list of the best goldfish tank mates for your aquarium:
5 Best Tank Mates to Keep with Goldfish
OUR TOP PICK
1. Newts
Why We Love them:
Get along great with goldfish
Fascinating to watch
Helps eat uneaten food
Description:
Historically, newts have long been kept as a companion for goldfish. They are peaceful and low-maintenance animals that can live for up to 15 years! Unlike some species, they only grow to about 5″ in length (if that) and lack frilly gills that goldfish may find interesting to pick at. They are most comfortable in cooler temperatures as well.
- You’ll want a tight fitting lid or a tank with a wide rim to keep these guys from escaping.
- Easy to care for – newts should be fed 1-2x per week with small earthworms or frozen bloodworms.
- These guys occasionally like something to sit on something out of water. A floating piece of wood or other land platform is recommended.
- Avoid the use of strong power filters that could injure the newt.
2. Snails
Why We Love them:
Clean up algae and break down organic waste in the tank
Offer attractive colors and patterns to the aquarium
Get along well with goldfish – peaceful and many are too big to eat
Description:
Snails are a superior alternative to algae-eating fish like Plecos. Because they are peaceful goldfish tank mates, you don’t have to worry about them hurting your fish – but you still get the benefits of algae removal. They come in all colors, shapes, and sizes for you to choose from. Some people even use smaller snails as a food source for their goldies. Larger snails are ideal if you are looking for something to help keep the aquarium cleaner without getting eaten. When it comes to identifying and destroying rotting plant material or being your mini algae scrubbing cleanup crew, these guys can’t be beaten! (Warning: you might find you spend more time watching them than you do your actual fish!)
Why We Love it:
The only shrimp big enough not to get eaten by bigger goldfish!
Doesn’t require acidic water conditions like most other shrimp species
Keeps the aquarium cleaner by foraging for food scraps on the filter intake
Description:
Most goldfish would devour any shrimp in rather short order – but not the Bamboo Shrimp. This fellow is just too big to fit in their mouths! As adults, they are 4″ long. Another super cool thing about them is that once they settle into your aquarium, they change color from simple brown to either bright red or blue (most commonly)! They can even change color based on their mood. As far as requirements go, they aren’t demanding, but don’t like to live alone – be sure to get at least one Bamboo Shrimp friend. Shrimps have a very low bioload on the tank and are fascinating to watch. The best part? They don’t need warm temperatures (though they do just fine in warm water too) and can tolerate a range of 68-85 degrees F. They love tanks with lots of plants and enjoy grazing on algae.
Why We Love it:
Beautiful little loach with very interesting patterns
Fairs best in water on the cooler side
Eats algae and uneaten food from the bottom of the tank
Description:
The Hillstream loach (or Butterfly loach), like goldfish, is native to Asian waters and is a peaceful fish with an intricate pattern. Unlike suckerfish, their mouths are not equipped to do any damage to a goldfish. This makes them an excellent alternative to plecos for a fancy goldfish tank. These fish grow to be 2.5-3″ large and enjoy areas of the tank that have faster-moving water. They love algae and will graze on any they can find, as well as sinking algae tabs. Some find blanched kale leaves make an excellent food source for them, and kale is not quickly consumed by the goldfish. Hillstream loaches prefer colder water ranging from 61-75 degrees F. They can grow up to 4″ in length, and are best kept as fancy goldfish tank mates. These fish can be challenging to find as they are very difficult to breed in captivity. Reticulated Hillstream loaches have a stronger color pattern and are even more rare. If eBay doesn’t have them, you can try Amazon here.
Why We Love it:
Does fantastic in cold water
Usually fast enough to escape getting munched
Provides a nice contrast to the colors and size of a goldfish
Description:
Many fish keepers have had success with keeping their slower-moving fancy goldfish with White Cloud minnows. The white clouds are usually fast enough that the goldfish don’t catch them. They’re also one of the few other fish species (like goldfish) that tolerate cooler water as well as warm water. And the best part? Their streamlined appearance make a nice contrast to larger, more deep-bodied goldfish. White Clouds come in several variations, including golden and silver. There are even long-finned white clouds if you want something extra special. They do best when kept in schooling groups of 5 or more.
Why We Love it:
Comes in many interesting colors and patterns
Tolerates very cold water
A good option to pair with slim-bodied fish
Description:
A coldwater fish native to Asia, the Weather loach (also called Dojo loach) is an easy, typically peaceful pet with few demands. They have been occasionally known to nip at slower-moving fancy goldfish, so goldfish keepers find they do best with slim-bodied fish such as Commons, Comets and Shubunkins and make a good addition to a pond. Dojos can be found in a wide range of colors, from bright solid gold without spots and dark eyes (known as the Golden Dojo) or brassy, silver or brown variations with or without spots. The name “Weather loach” refers to its ability to sense changes in barometric pressure, causing it to behave erratically before a storm or weather front. They can become tame enough to eat from your hand! Dojos can grow to be quite large (10-12 inches long) so sufficient room is required, as well as a fine sand substrate for them to burrow in. They also prefer to be kept in groups of 3 or more to prevent the stress of being kept alone. These fish tolerate a wide range of temperatures, from 50-77 degrees F.
Reasons Only Some Fish are Compatible with Goldfish
It’s important to select only suitable goldfish tank mates to avoid the problems below.
1. Temperature: Goldfish Prefer Cooler Water than Most Other Kinds of Fish
Tropical fish (such as Cichlids, loaches, tetras, and others) need to live in temperatures that would be too toasty for goldfish and carry far less dissolved oxygen.
Goldfish (slim-bodied ones anyway) prefer temps in the 65-80 degree F range with changes from season to season.
Tropicals don’t require periodic cold spells, which help goldfish to shed their excess fat. In fact, colder water may harm their health.
Of course, in a home aquarium, many times seasonal fluctuations do not occur even for goldfish not kept with tropical fish.
2. Aggression: Your Goldfish Can Get Picked on
There’s no doubt about it:
Getting picked on isn’t fun.
For goldfish, it can be very stressful.
Putting some other types of fish in with your goldfish all too often leads to bullying or injury. Your goldfish may end up spending its days hiding in terror from its persecutor.
For example:
Many algae eaters (such as the plecostemos) are responsible for a large number of goldfish injuries regularly, as their suction cup mouth can fix on the side of the goldfish and chew away at their tasty slime coat.
Want to know the worst part?
They typically do their dirty deeds when nobody is around to watch them.
This leads goldfish owners to think their fish are sick when suddenly they wake up to a large red sore on their goldy’s side.
Even the supposedly peaceful Bristlenose Pleco has been reported to attack goldfish!
Koi are notoriously overbearing towards their smaller fancy cousins and should never be housed in the same tank with them. They also get much, much larger than goldfish and do best in ponds.
If this happens in your tank, don’t blame the bully. The fish isn’t being mean – it is just doing what it naturally does.
Right now, if you have your goldfish in with them, get them out immediately.
You may have to find another home or start up another tank (we’ll get to that later).
3. Your Other Fish May Get Digested by Your Goldfish
It’s a fact:
A goldfish will eat any fish that fits in its mouth – if it can catch it.
So while it is still young your other fish may be okay…
… Until after another year or so, when the goldfish has doubled in size.
One day you might look in the tank and think your other fish went *poof* into thin air.
Since they do it with their own babies… they probably don’t think twice about turning their tank mate into sushi!
Slim-bodied breeds will probably turn any fish smaller than themselves into shark-bait.
Most people don’t have problems with White Clouds getting eaten by their fancies, but occasionally it can happen if the goldfish figures it out – and one by one, they’ll all disappear.
The other fish have to be fast or large enough so this can’t happen.
Bonus Reason: Goldfish Have Different Diet Requirements than other Species
It’s a fact that goldfish require a large amount of vegetable material to keep their digestive tract working correctly.
Too much of a high protein diet can lead to swim bladder troubles.
The other type of fish you get will probably have many different nutritional requirements than your goldfish.
This brings us to the next question:
So What other Fish Do You Put with Your Goldfish?
The good news is, you don’t have to have one isolated little goldfish as the only inhabitant of your beautiful aquarium.
(That is if it is large enough).
Goldfish are community fish and get along great with other goldfish and some other select species the majority of the time under normal circumstances. Some people think they even form bonds with each other like lifelong friends.
There are some things to keep in mind, which are:
1. The size of the fish
It isn’t a good idea in most cases to put really small or young goldfish in with a “Shamu” sized buddy.
One will end up getting all the food, and the other one going hungry – which can lead to malnourishment.
2. The breed of the goldfish
Goldfish come in such a wide variety of shapes and body modifications.
While goldfish are usually peaceful, not all breeds are necessarily a good fit.
Some have very sensitive eye areas and may be more prone to getting picked on by more hardy companions – such as the Ryukin or Comet.
Make sure to research before even mixing different breeds of goldfish for that very reason.
For example:
Black moors do best with other fancy goldfish like fantails, Orandas, Ryukins, or Bubble eyes because stronger, athletic slim-bodied fish like Common or Comets can out-compete them for food.
Related Post: Aquarium Fish Alternatives to Consider
When in Doubt, Always Remember that Less Stress is Best!
Diversity in having different goldfish tank mates is interesting and important, no doubt.
But so is the happiness of your goldfish – and your sanity.
Get this:
Many times it’s just a bad idea to add more fish into the tank PERIOD because there just isn’t enough room to support the tank’s inhabitants.
This leads to all kinds of problems…
… Which can include having your fish feeling very stressed from overcrowding.
I think we all want the best for our pets.
But don’t lose hope!
You can always keep a separate community tank if you absolutely must have a variety of other types of tropical or saltwater fish. That way you won’t have to deal with any of the problems that come with mixing goldfish with other kinds of fish.
Here’s a tip:
Just be sure you don’t go too crazy, as too many tanks can make you stressed out if you are too busy to maintain them all. 
Whatever you do, always be sure you quarantine any new inhabitants before introducing them to your aquarium to avoid disease outbreaks.
One method that works for many smaller species (such as keeping betta fish with goldfish) is to use a hang-on breeding box attachment for your tank.
I explain how to do that successfully.
Read More: How Betta Fish Can Live with Goldfish
Some Final Thoughts
There have been and always will be people who claim to have success mixing many other different types of goldfish tank mates than the ones mentioned here.
Granted, there are times when it does seem to work out every so often.
However:
These are the exception, NOT the rule – in my humble opinion.
Things may seem to go “swimmingly” for a while…
But sooner or later, 99% of the time you will run into trouble.
One thing is for sure:
When it comes to goldfish keeping it is always better to be safe than sorry!
The risk of injury or even death to any of your tank’s inhabitants just isn’t worth it.
You don’t want to make any fatal mistakes with your beloved pet, which is why we wrote the complete guide to goldfish care, The Truth About Goldfish.
It has all the answers you will need for keeping a thriving, harmonious, disease-free goldfish aquarium.
You can check it out here.
Can a comet fish and black telescope fish be in the same tank? I had the comet fish first and he seemed kinda lonely and I looked up online that said they are axial animales so i went to the pet store and got another fish which is the cute buggy eyed telescope fish I didn’t think much on which one made the best friend anyways I put them in the same tank pretty large tank. Anyways the comet fishes at first chased the telescope fish and bumped in to it so I thought maybe one day see how it goes do the comet fish kinds stoped chasing the telescope fish he did it maybe like 3 x that I saw but so the day passed by and then the comet fish started jumping it did it twice it scared me so I watch him and decide to take the telescope fish out and put it in another tank on its own. So my question is did I do the right thing or am I jus paranoid and it’s okay for them to be together. And is it fine to have just one gold fish on its own does he need friends ? If not does the telescope fish need a friend? I’m just a little confused / heartbroken
Telescopes and comets don’t mix. Comets are way too active and moors can’t see well. They probably each need separate living quarters and separate friends 🙂
New to goldfish. Have 5 shabumkins (the 6th got hole in the head yesterday 🙁 . In an outdoor pond, how do I clear up the poop? Wondering if that is why I lost Fishy 6. Having read your info, going to change the food from flakes (been given some bad adviice clearly!) Just worrying about the pop piling up in the pond (which is huge tractor tyre, lined with a good quality filer).
You will probably want to use a siphon/pump to give it a good water change.
A couple of weeks in with intense study into keeping fish (who knew it was so complex!) and I’m thrilled to say the pond has been ‘hoovered’, water changed, plants added, rocks added, levels checked twice daily and we now have a perfectly balanced pond, fish are lovely and lively again, I have relaxed and situation all round is A1! ?
Great to hear, Helen! 😀
I had a Comet and a Fantail goldfish in a tank once, and surprisingly it went well. Both got its own share of food, as the Comet, despite being fast, only takes one or two in its mouth at once and swim in circles near the base of the tank as it chews, leaving the Fantail to come to surface and gobble at least five at once and swim around lazily. I had no idea about the risks of having two different goldfish types back then. 🙂
Glad yours got along well, AyaLittleComet! Fantails can be one of the exceptions to fancy fish that do well with slim-bodied fish, but it definitely depends on the fish.
I have some uhh… different types of fish. I got 3 common goldfish plus I set a minnow net and got 4 small minnows, 5 pollywogs, and 2 small water bugs. So far, they’re doing okay. I’ve had em 4 about a week and they seem fine.
The minnows may eventually be eaten. Hopefully the water bugs will do alright 😉
So, my goldfish(an inch) keeps picking on my mystery snail. How can I prevent this?
Maybe try providing more hiding places for the snail, such as plants, cave hides etc. Your fish might also be bored. Make sure it has some fresh veggies to eat at all times.
I have a koi pond – 5 koi and 1 fantail goldfish. I got all but 1 koi at the same time and everybody gets along, I just make sure the goldfish gets some food as he’s so slow. I live in the NE and, while the koi stay out and “hibernate” during the winter, I try to bring the goldfish inside because he had some swim bladder issues in a previous winter and I’ve read that cold weather can cause that to happen (although I didn’t move him in time last year so he stayed outside and survived a brutal winter – maybe he’d be fine staying out with the koi but I worry!) I have a nice 30 gal aquarium for him and was thinking of getting him a friend or 2 but after reading your helpful goldfish tips here I guess I’ll either let him be a solitary fishy or get a companion fantail. Also considering making him a year-round inside resident, otherwise I have an empty aquarium every year from May to October. Anyway, thanks for saving me from buying incompatible fish to keep my goldfish company!
You’re welcome Jennie!
I currently have two fantail goldfish that I’ve had for over 2 1/2 years (each about 6-7 inches long) and I’m wondering if they’d be compatible with a Shubunkin goldfish? I’ll be getting a new tank within the next couple weeks that will be around 50 gallons and I’d love to add 2 or 3 more fish in it. I find both breeds very beautiful and would love for them to live together.
You can try, but you may have issues with the Shubbie out competing the others for food. They are way faster and more agile than fancies.
Can goldfish be mixed with a ping pong?
I assume you mean a ping pong pearlscale? If so yes, but it is recommended to keep them only with other breeds of fancy goldfish. 🙂
hello,
can I add oto or bristlenose plecos to my fancy goldfish tank?
Wouldn’t recommend it, plecos are notorious for preying on them at night.
Had a “little helper” at the store who couldn’t leave without a fish, picked up an algae eater. It is not a pleco, it is very fast and small, and it’s light gray with a few small dots. I have a betta tank and a goldfish tank. (Seperate) Which one would it do better in? ?
It might be a pictus catfish, probably best left with the betta.
Awesome! Thanks. Also he is in my .8 gal refugium (connected to butterfly tank) with my betta because helper gave him 5 algae wafers which partially dissolved over night and left the tank a horrific disgusting green mess. ? Had to evacuate.to refugium for a while. Also the tertra filter in the bettas 5 gallon tank is to much for him and I really need some way to perhaps make the output flow less rough, any suggestions? I can’t keep the fish in the refugium for long term, because of water quality issues…I tried tying a sponge to it and within a few hours it started stinking horribly. Any advice welcome. ?
Sponges can help moderate flows, if they stink there could be another issue going on such as overfeeding
Wow. One of the most amazing sites I have come across. I kept fish as a 10 year old 30 years ago with typical platy, sword, tetra, molly etc. community, including doing some fun breeding, but got out for a long time. Got back in 8 months ago realizing goldies are several things…BEAUTIFUL, graceful, have their own personality (they come to the glass when I walk by hoping to get fed), hearty and cheaper to enjoy since no heater needed. Set up a 29G with 6 – 1 inch fancy\’s from the LFS, (Oranda, Black Moor, Calico split tail, solid white split tail and 2 varied dorsal and caudal fin color orange split tails), knowing that was a temp home for those guys until they grew.
Bought soon after a 75G on E-Bay with a beautiful oak stand and canopy. I am refinishing it and have been buying components over time when on crazy sale to re-home in the fall 3 inch goldies. Two Aquaclear 70\’s, a Lees UGF (I\’m old school) powered by 2 Eheim 400\’s, ATI Prefilter\’s on the intake, Fluval 3.0 programmable plant light, and a ton of Anubias, Val\’s and Java growing amazing in the 29G to move over…it will be amazing.
The 75 will be a lot of room for 18 inches of goldies at first, so thinking of about 12 white clouds (you like them with goldies)(I had 6 in the 29 originally, but 2 died soon after I brought them home (they were only a few months old so didn\’t adapt well and left only 4)). I saw on LiveAquaria that Panda Corys only get about 2 inches long, live on the bottom, (they are amazing looking) and thrive in 68 degree tanks. I wanted a bottom feeder in the 75G when the goldies where young.
I am thinking my 6 varied fancies, a dozen white clouds which only live 2 or 3 years, but will be active and fun to watch, can replace as appropriate, maybe 6 Panda Cory\’s that are only a 2 -3 year life expectancy, and the big part I never though of, until I read your article, maybe 3 or 4 of the Bamboo Shrimp you said are good goldie companions. I think that could be an awesome tank inhabitant to watch for the next 3 or so years until the goldies get bigger and take over.
Thoughts on this??? Any comments are greatly appreciated.
I have never tried Corys with goldfish but I hear it works well for some. Your tank sounds like it’s going to be fantastic!
Hello Pure Goldfish! Would RL(rubber lip) plecos do good with goldfish? I’m thinking of stocking my 30 gal with a fantail, a butterfly, an apple snail and an RL pleco and am wondering of they will live harmoniously? I was also wondering of plecos eat leftover food and/or fish poop?
Replied to your comment on the other post 🙂
What can I feed my common goldfish besides the pellets? Is there any fruits or veggies I can give him?
You may want to check out this post.
Interesting. How would you go about quarantining a hillstream Loach before introduction to a tank? Is the process much different than the quarantine for the goldfish?
Also, is there a way to keep snails from escaping without a lid? I have a setup where part of the lid remains open.
Anyway, thanks.
I’d isolate the loach for about 4 weeks. And possibly MinnFinn at standard dosage. Depends on the snail, I’ve never had my ramshorns escape but nerites & mysteries YES.
We’re pretty new to fishkeeping – my roommate and I have a 5 gallon betta tank and a 29 gallon we’re working on to be our community tank, but when we went to the fair a few weeks ago we somehow ended up with two fish… a little bit of research tells us we have 2 baby shubunkin goldfish. The largest tank we can afford/accommodate until we move next year is a 55 gallon (we picked it up last week), but is that too small for them? They’re about 2″ long, hanging out in a 20 gallon terrarium right now while the bigger tank cycles. Do you think they’ll be okay? If so, do you think it’s too small to keep some minnows with them? I want them to be happy and healthy, and we’re building a community tank already but I keep seeing stuff about how goldfish like to have friends.
Hi! I previously read this (or another article of yours) about Mystery/Apple Snails, saying how they were such good companions and stuff. Well, it turns out my goldfish ate the poor thing while it was asleep by pushing it onto it’s back? I thought the Black Mystery Snail would be fine since they haven’t previously picked on it but the poor thing was eaten from the inside out. Do you know what I can do to prevent my Blue Apple from having the same fate?
Sorry to hear about that! I know they will eat sick/dead mystery snails. Some really big slim-bodied fish are snail-suckers and will eat healthy ones, but this is not very common. I’d be inclined to think your other healthy snail will be fine.
Hi everyone, just wondering if I can put glofish in with our goldfish
Seems the temperature is pretty close, and glofish probably aren’t aggressive… you could try. If your goldfish is big it might eat them though.
Great Post! I have often considered goldfish solo-fliers, but it does seem that the size of the tank really is the key.
Have you ever kept clams with your goldfish? I saw some gold Asian clams that look pretty neat and have the same water parameters, and thought it might be interesting to add a couple for “natural” filtration! My tank right now has fancy goldfish and mystery snails. Thanks for the great website!
I have not personally tried them but I don’t see why not! The main thing is probably figuring out how to get them food without the fish eating it first. Keeping them in a hang on breeder box would allow you to feed them without the fish interfering, while they purify the water.
Question: Anybody else have luck with one male Beta in with their Goldfish? I’ve done this numerous times and they’ve gotten along great. Even now in two of my tanks, each has a Beta in with my goldfish and it’s been for a few years. The one in my five Goldfish tank, I swear he thinks he’s a Goldfish! Always swims with them and when one was sick he was constantly coming over to check on them. Not in an aggressive way at all either. It was like he knew something was wrong.
All the pet shop people tell me not to put them in the same tank but I’ve always had really good luck with it?
So far it’s working for me too.
Quick question if I wanted to get some dojo loaches to go with my gold fish would they eat the Same food or is there another kind I should get for them?
I believe they eat most of the same food as goldfish 🙂
Can a Ryukin and an Oranda stay together in a 36 gallon tank?
I am thinking on putting a Ryukin, a couple of Orandas, and a small Comet that I have (and hence cannot throw away) in a 36 gallon tank? Will that be OK? Will they be compatible?
Sure!
I have inherited a single-tailed goldfish (Alex). Who is now about 3 inches long. I am not sure what sex Alex is. Alex gets lonely and I’d like to get another fish to co exist with him/her. I don’t want any baby goldfish! The tank is a good size for Alex and another fish of the same size but no bigger. Recommendations on type of fish would be most welcome. Many thanks!
If you don’t want babies and get another goldfish you can do nothing and they will eat the eggs. Some folks keep rainbow fish with goldfish they get about that size.
Hiya! So I’ve got an empty 110 gal tank ready for use, and two Fantails ready for moving. These Fantails have grown up together and are pretty compatible and nice to their other past tank mates (snails). I was thinking of introducing a Blood Parrot into the tank, since I’ve always wanted one. I keep the tank water at about 78 degrees, so the temperature should be fine. Do you think that the goldfish and blood parrot will be compatible? Provided of course that there’s plenty of places to hide. If not, I can always put the parrot in another tank.
I have personally never tried that combo but some folks report that it works for them. You could try it and see how it goes.
Pure Goldfish February 17, 2017 at 4:42 am – Reply
Telescopes and comets don’t mix. Comets are way too active and moors can’t see well. They probably each need separate living quarters and separate friends
I Have a moor a sarasa comet and a canary yellow and they all get along fine.
Hi Meredith!
I currently have 3 zebra danios in my 29 gal to help with the cycling process. So far so good. However, my goal is to add a black moor and fan tail. My concern is I dont know what I’ll do with the zebras. If I keep them, I’ll add at least 3 more so they have a bigger school. But my question is, is there any way they can coexist with the goldies? Ive been hearing mixed opinions from different sources and would hate to have to disown them once the goldies come home. Any way they can coexist?
The only way to know is to try! Worst that can happen is the goldfish eating them (aside from disease issues that is). Sometimes they do just fine together.
Thank you for your reply! I don’t mind if they got eaten because its natural and happens inevitably sometimes. My main concern is the zebras possibly nipping at the fins of the goldies, since some sources have said is a risk. But again I always hear mixed reviews. And I was planning on getting juvenile goldies so it may help that they grow up together.
That can definitely help.
Hello ,
A technical question :
What do you mean by hillstream loach? as you know hillstream consist several families such as Gastromyzons ,sewellias and … .
you uploaded picture of sewellia lineolata and said \”their mouths are not equipped to do any damage to a goldfish\”.
the Gastromyzon ctenocephalus has a different mouth (its picture link is here :
https://images.app.goo.gl/dngYPGCJs88YmAQa7 ) that is significantly wider and bigger than sewellia lineolata (https://images.app.goo.gl/mvbLbwjVnbRsjsoR8).
is Gastromyzon safe for fancy goldfish?
thank you for this perfect site
My understanding is they are both fine.