Freshwater Refugium Filters for Goldfish & Other Aquariums

The concept of “refugium” is relatively foreign to most freshwater fishkeepers.

But they can have an important role in your tank!

Today I’m here to talk about the advantages of having a refugium – even a small one – on your freshwater setup.

Whether you keep goldfish and/or another kind of fish, this is something you should know about.

Let’s get into it!

Why Have a Freshwater Refugium Filter?

Here’s an example of a beautiful freshwater refugium setup:

I just love how it’s so peaceful.

They make such amazing filters for goldfish tanks (or just about any other kind of freshwater fish filter).

And here’s why:

1. Possibility to Make the Tank Self-Sustaining

The ultimate goal of an effective refugium setup is to help make the tank partially or entirely self-sustaining.

This means FAR less maintenance on your part.

Some report the reduced workload of doing a water change once a month or even once every several months.

Obviously the bigger and older your fuge is, the further it will take you towards that goal.

The more self-sustaining your aquarium is, the less work for you.

You can even enjoy having more aquariums!

2. Nitrate Reduction

Most filters are designed to remove ammonia and nitrite.

But what about nitrate?

Anaerobic filtration is best accomplished in a deep, dark area with a slow flow rate.

The bottom of a refugium equipped with plants is the perfect environment for this.

You can even use Seachem Matrix or Aragonite for nitrate reduction and replenishing alkalinity.

3. Fish Separation

The possibilities refugiums create are not limited to just filtration.

You can safely keep fishes of different sizes/types all in one system.

If you have a problem where one of your tank’s inhabitants is getting picked on, it’s a low-stress solution to get them to safety.

Did your fish just have babies and you need a cycled place to house the eggs and/or grow out the fry?  Their water will continue to be filtered and heated but they will be separate from the main tank.

It’s a way to keep the water as clean as your main tank – with less work.

Want to keep some more delicate species (animals or plants) that would be lunch in with your goldfish (such as loaches, small shrimp, snails, bettas, frogs… the list is endless)?

No big deal.

If the purpose of your refugium is to filter the water, I wouldn’t suggest keeping fish in it (more poop!).

Also:

As a quarantine tank for sick fish (injured ones would be fine) it’s not recommended to have connected systems as it can transpit disease.

4. Biodiversity

Refugiums are used to house tiny animal life, such as little shrimp (i.e. ghost shrimp, cherry shrimp), small snails (such as mini ramshorn, bladder), copepods and microscopic worms.

These little creatures improve the tank’s biodiversity – replicating a natural ecosystem.

Here’s my Amano shrimp/snail HOB refugium first set up:

And after just 2 weeks since I took this photo (the Pearl Weed has literally doubled in size!):

Currently I have Ramshorn & Bladder snails with Pearl Weed (I do NOT keep the lights on 24/7 for this as it would stress the shrimp).

What I love about this is while the snails lay eggs constantly, the snails are a delicious treat for my goldfish.

Feeding the extras to my hungry goldies not only prevents overpopulation, but gives them a nutritious natural foraging source right there on the tank.

The same is true of the plants.

Biodiversity helps your tank be more balanced and favorable to healthy fish.

Where do they come from?

The larger ones are introduced by you as the fishkeeper (shrimp, snails.)

The microscopic ones arrive much like the bacteria in your filter – over time, and seemingly out of thin air.

As time goes on, the biodiversity increases.

5. Toxin Absorption

The mud at the bottom of a fuge plays a special role in removing toxins from the water.

Many of these toxins are from the water source itself.

6. Hiding Stuff

This is a benefit of using a larger refugium.

You can pack some of your more unsightly equipment in it and free up the display tank.

UV sterilizer, alkalinity replenisher, heaters, extra sponge filters or other internal filters – just about whatever you can think of.

7. Greater Stocking Capacity

Refugiums can support a greater bioload than most other kinds of filters due to their nitrate reduction and waste processing capabilities.

What You Need

Plants

I just can’t see doing a refugium without plants.

Live plants play a HUGE role in purifying the water in a fuge.

You can use any fast-growing plant, and you don’t have to worry about it getting eaten – it’s totally protected.

Some good options are:

  • Wisteria
  • Hornwort
  • Myrio Green
  • Java moss
  • Luffy moss balls

If you grow plants that your fish would eat, that’s even better, because you can feed the pruning remains to your fish!

Pruning it is important (and will be needed if your plant is happy).

Lighting

You will need lighting.

Without it, your plants won’t grow quickly.

I recommend the FugeRay LED or StingRAY LED.

You can get it together with their awesome HOB refugium here for the best deal.

By default it comes with an adjustable water pump, but you can also use an airstone if you prefer a lower flow and don’t mind the extra noise.

Either way, it will work fantastic.

These lights should ideally be left on 24/7 for maximum performance.

The way to accomplish this without disturbing your fish (for a HOB or behind tank setup) would be to have a dark aquarium background that blocks out the majority of the light and/or set it to “moonlight” at night.

Mud

Mud – let’s talk about it.

Some use sand for their refugiums, but the general consensus is mud is the way to go.

In a goldfish tank as a substrate, a mud bottom would make a disgusting mess with them plowing through it all the time.

Your tank would be in a constant brown fog.

But mud has so many benefits, such as nitrate reduction, fish color enhancement and remineralizing the water!

This means fewer water changes.

Plants also love it.

Through the use of a refugium (either in a sump or a HOB refugium) you can have mud in a low-current zone totally separate from fish that would stir it up.

1-2″ of dry packed mud is recommended.

Now:

What is the best kind of mud to use?

Freshwater Miracle Mud is specifically formulated for refugiums.

I would like to try a half top soil, half calcium bentonite clay mix and see how it goes (will update you on how that works out).

Here are instructions on how to add it.

As far as maintenance goes:

Half of the mud should be changed out once a year to replenish the minerals and replenish its function.

Pretty simple.

One nice thing about refugiums is you can add some porous rock such as Seachem Matrix or Aragonite (to replenish alkalinity) and further assist in nitrate reduction.

Refugium Container

This can be as simple or as complicated – as well as as beautiful or as unsightly – as you want it to be.

The bottom line?

Water needs to be able to go in one side and out the other.

Fish from your main display tank should not be able to have access to it.

The bigger it is the better of a filter it will make and the more fish you can house in it (if you want to use it to house fish).

More on what styles of refugiums you can use later.

How it Works

A very basic, general picture:

Water is slowly moved into an isolated chamber that contains a mud bottom, plants and possibly tiny creatures like snails.

This gentle current creates the perfect environment for nitrate reduction deep in the mud bottom and helps the plants suck up nutrients.

The purified water is then returned to the main tank.

Keep reading to learn how to set it up.

The 3 Main Ways to Set Up A Refugium Filter

There are three ways I’ve found to set up a refugium.

Method one is the easier option and probably the most affordable.  It is great if you have very limited space.

Method three is best if you have a larger surface area for your tank to rest on.

Method three is the largest (therefore the most powerful) but is not for novices.  You will also need to either do a ton of research and planning to create a DIY version or spend a hefty chunk on a pre-made solution.

Let’s start with method one.

Option 1 [Easy/Affordable]: Small HOB Refugium

Pros: Hurt/aggressive fish isolation, protecting eggs and baby fish, water remineralization

Cons: Smaller size means less effective filtration, limited storage for plants and less nitrate reduction.  

For those who don’t want to spend a lot of money or understand a lot of technical stuff, I’ve found the solution.

The HOB refugium.

It sits behind the tank and is crystal clear, so you can see your fish.

And if you don’t want to see it, no problem – all you need is a tank background or grow some tall plants in the back of the tank.  This is totally a personal preference thing.

They make refugiums that stay completely inside the tank, but personally I’m not as crazy about these (too distracting and take up space if they’re big enough to do anything).

I really like the Finnex External Refugium/Breeder Box.

It holds .8 gallons and is good for a tank from 40-50 gallons.

If you want to save money you can go for Marina’s Hang on Breeding Box and do like other fishkeepers have done, and convert it into a refugium for my 10 gallon tank.

It’s a bit more cost effective and is powered by an air pump rather than a water pump (though you can use a water pump with a bit of modification).

For lighting I use this nifty little plant growing light.

Option 2: Side-By-Side Tank Refugium

This method allows for much more water volume and – as a result – filtration capabilities.

More water, more plants, more surface area for mud to do it’s nitrifying and nitrate-removing thing…

… It doesn’t get much better than that!

Here’s how it works:

One tank is placed behind or next to the other.

It’s okay if the refugium tank is smaller than the main tank, but the height of both tanks must be the same for this to work as described without flooding.

This can be done by propping up the smaller tank with bricks or boards – or something nicer if you can find it.

Warning: If one pump starts failing or shuts off entirely, you WILL have a flood with this method. :'(

Two identical submersible water pumps are needed (one to go in the main tank and one to go in the refugium), each with an adapter for the prefilter sponge on the intake.

Why sponges?

The sponge on the main tank’s pump prevents debris from going into the fuge.

The sponge on the refugium’s pump prevents little critters getting into your main system (this could be anything from shrimp, snails or fry).

Rubber tubing is also required to connect them – transferring water from one to the other.  This will be connected to the outlets of the pumps.

A plastic loop is useful to run into the fuge from the rubber tube on the main tank.

A spray bar is recommended for the return from the fuge to distribute the current.

Don’t forget the light! 😉

Now, you might be thinking:

“Why not just use a bigger tank instead of two smaller ones?”

Good question.

Yes, you combine water volume, so it is like having a bigger tank in that respect.

But one tank – the fuge – is primarily for filtration.

A separate tank altogether has these important advantages:

  • A 24/7 photoperiod is required for the fuge to perform at its best.  If your main tank’s lights were on all the time it would stress your fish. With a separate tank, you can block out the excess light with a tank background or cloth.
  • Can be hidden behind main display tank like a HOB.  This is not possible if you only use one tank.
  • No need to use silicone and dividers to section off part of your main tank, which not only is a hassle but looks unsightly.

Option 3 [Advanced]: Sump

Wet/dry sumps located under your tank can be designed to hold refugiums.

These definitely have their advantages, such as being able to add a sock to catch debris and adding a lot of extra gallons to the tank’s overall volume.

Now – the problem with sumps?

They are expensive and can be VERY COMPLICATED to set up.

For starters, you need to either drill the tank (yikes!) or use an expensive overflow box to prevent spills in case of a power outage.

It requires a LOT of planning and researching and at this point in my life is beyond my paygrade to explain 😉

If you can or want to do it, great.

I think if you have a large tank and want an efficient filtration option that really cuts down on your water changes, go for it.

The following video provides a lot of detail about a Discus refugium sump setup.

Some fishkeepers have Discus, a species of fish that is extremely delicate and needs perfect water quality (kind of like some of the more fragile fancy goldfish).

Conclusion

I hope you learned something new in this post.

The concept of a refugium filter is certainly fascinating to me (maybe that rubbed off?).

What are your thoughts?

Feel free to leave a comment to let me know.

2019-01-30T21:43:24+00:00

Leave A Comment